Evaluating Pollination and Weed Control Strategies in Mesotunnel Systems for Organic Muskmelon Production

Project Director: Kephas Mphande, Iowa State University

Project Overview

Bacterial wilt, a disease caused by pathogens carried by spotted and striped cucumber beetles, poses a significant threat to cucurbit producers. Organic cucurbit producers are particularly at-risk for bacterial wilt, since NOP-compliant options for managing cucumber beetles are limited.

Several physical exclusion strategies (low/high tunnels, mesotunnels, insect netting) for cucumber beetles have been tested at small scales, with variable success due to challenges managing cucurbit pollination and weeds.

This study, conducted at Iowa State University, evaluated (1) the efficacy of several pollination and weed control strategies and (2) insect pest/disease prevalence within mesotunnels in an organic, commercial-scale Athena muskmelon production system.

Farmer Takeaways

  • Full-season mesotunnel coverage may provide superior protection from insect pests (i.e. striped and spotted cucumber beetles) and insect-borne diseases (i.e. bacterial wilt) than other mesotunnel systems, resulting in higher marketable muskmelon yields at harvest.
  • Despite higher materials costs for the full-season treatment, full-season mesotunnels may still be the most cost-efficient option for Athena muskmelon growers, as the full-season treatment was resulted in substantially higher yields than other treatments.

Project Objectives and Approach

Evaluate pollination strategies and insect pest/disease prevalence under mesotunnels in commercial-scale organic Athena muskmelon plots

  • Treatments for the pollination trial included: (1) full-season: mesotunnels remained closed for the entire growing season (from transplant to harvest), with a bumblebee hive introduced when the first female flowers appeared (approximately 3 weeks after transplanting); (2) open-ends: mesotunnel netting was opened at both ends for 2 weeks during bloom, then resealed; (3) on-off-on: the entire length of the mesotunnel netting on a 150-ft subplot was removed for 2 weeks during bloom, then resealed.
  • Bumble bee activity was monitored regularly for each treatment, and at the end of the growing season, data was collected on Athena muskmelon yield (total, marketable, and unmarketable).
  • Data was collected regularly on insect pest prevalence and disease symptoms. If/when standard thresholds for pest/disease prevalence were surpassed, appropriate NOP-compliant control methods were deployed, including the application of copper hydroxide for fungal diseases and neem oil/pyrethrins/kaolin clay for cucumber beetles.

Evaluate the effectiveness of living mulches as an alternative weed control strategy in mesotunnels

  • Treatments for the weed control trial included: (1) landscape fabric covering the furrows between plastic-mulched rows; (2) teff sown in the furrows and mowed 3 weeks after seeding; (3) teff sown in the furrows and not mowed; (4) bare ground with mowing 3 weeks after transplanting; and (5) bare ground with no mowing.
  • Two days before the first muskmelon harvest, weeds were sampled, oven-dried, and weighed.

Compare the economic efficiency of each pollination and living mulch strategy

  • A partial budget analysis incorporating revenue and costs of materials and labor was performed to compare the relative cost-efficiency of each pollination and weed control treatment.

Key Findings

Pollinator activity is positively correlated with Athena muskmelon yields, with full-season mesotunnels allowing greater pollinator activity than the on-off-on and open-ends mesotunnel systems

  • The full-season treatment had the highest marketable yield during all three years and was significantly higher than that of the other two treatments in both 2020 and 2021.
  • Athena muskmelon yield was positively correlated with pollinator activity. Treatments with higher numbers of bumblebee visits to flowers (full-season and on-off-on treatments, respectively) experienced greater yields at harvest than treatments with lower or spatially-inconsistent bumblebee visits (open-ends treatment).

Full-season mesotunnels may provide significantly stronger insect pest and disease prevention for Athena muskmelons than either open-end or on-off-on mesotunnel systems

  • The full-season treatment was the most effective at excluding insect pests (most notably, striped and spotted cucumber beetles). The on-off-on treatment had the highest number of insect pests of the three mesotunnel treatments.
  • The full-season treatment was the most effective at preventing bacterial wilt in Athena muskmelons.

Resources

Mphande, K., S. Badilla-Arias, N. Cheng, J.F. González-Acuña, A. Nair, W. Zhang, and M.L. Gleason. 2024. Evaluating Pollination and Weed Control Strategies under Mesotunnel Systems for Organic Muskmelon Production in Iowa. HortTechnology 34:265-279.

Read More

Location

Iowa

Collaborators

Sharon Badilla-Arias, Iowa State University
Nieyan Cheng, Iowa State University
Jose Gonzalez-Acuna, Iowa State University
Ajay Nair, Iowa State University
Wendong Zhang, Cornell University
Mark Gleason, Iowa State University

Region

Midwest

Topic

Weed Management, Disease Management, Insect/Pest Management

Category

Vegetables/Fruits

Year Published

2024

Have a question or a suggestion?

Use the button to contact our team, including resource suggestions for the Hub or Extension Directory.

Created and maintained by the Organic Farming Research Foundation.