Creep Stop: Integrating Biological, Cultural, and Mechanical/Physical Tools for Long-term Suppression of Creeping Perennial Weeds in Northern Great Plains and Pacific Northwest Cropping Systems
Project Director
Patrick M. Carr
Year Funded
2018
Award Number
2018-51300-28432
Funded Institution
Montana State University
Grant Program
OREI (Organic Agriculture Research and Extension Initiative)
USDA NIFA Report (alternate)
Project Overview
Two creeping perennial weeds – Canada thistle (Cirsium arvense) and field bindweed (Convovulus arvensus) – pose severe challenges to organic wheat, lentil, and other grain production in the Pacific Northwest (PNW) and Northern Great Plains (NGP). This project aimed to develop improved organic integrated weed management (IWM) for these two weeds, including biological (grazing, mites, pathogens), cultural (crop rotational sequence), and mechanical (mowing, tillage) tactics. Weed populations and their associated soil-root microbiomes were genotyped to evaluate genetic variables in weed response to control tactics.
Canada thistle collected from multiple sites in Washington, Montana, and North Dakota consistently hosted a core community of bacteria (28 taxa) and fungi (12 taxa) in the rhizosphere. An alfalfa hay crop (3 years) reduced Canada thistle and bindweed populations in a subsequent wheat crop as effectively as two years of intensive tillage (Noble sweep plow every 14-21 days), whereas various combinations of diversified annual crop rotations (cover and production crops), sheep grazing, and targeted tillage did not suppress these weeds. However, alfalfa reduced yields in lower-rainfall climates (14”/yr) due to soil moisture depletion, and the annual crop rotations yielded higher net economic returns. Treatments had no effect on soil microbiome or soil health.
Inoculation with rust fungus (Puccinia punctiformis) in combination with mowing reduced Canada thistle stem density more effectively than fungus + spring and fall disking.
Farmer Takeaways
(1) Canada thistle and field bindweed spread by seed and by vegetative means (creeping rhizomes). Suppression tactics and organic IWM must target both.
(2) Three years of alfalfa hay reduced perennial weeds as effectively as two years of tilled fallow, but depleted soil moisture and reduced wheat yields in lower-rainfall regions.
(3) The Noble sweep plow weakens creeping perennial weeds by severing shoots, whereas the mixing action of the rototiller replants and propagates bindweed fragments.
(4) Inoculating Canada thistle with thistle rust fungus as one component of the IWM strategy helps to weaken the weed’s growth.
Project Outputs
CREEP Stop: Organic Control of Canada Thistle and Field Bindweed in the Northern Great Plains and Pacific Northwest Regions | eOrganic Project Homepage
Thistle Rust: A Potential Biocontrol Agent to Help in the Management of Canada Thistle | Montana State University
Research Updates: CREEP Stop: Organic Control of Canada Thistle and Field Bindweed in the Northern Great Plains and Pacific Northwest Regions | eOrganic
Organic Bindweed and Canada Thistle Control Webinar w/ Greta Gramig | NDSU Extension
Chichinsky, D., Larson, C., Eberly, J., Menalled, F., & Seipel, T. 2023. Impact of Puccinia punctiformis on Cirsium arvense performance in a simulated crop sequence. Frontiers in Agronomy, 5.
Hettinger, K., Miller, Z., Hubbel, K., & Seipel, T. 2023. Crop rotation and cultivation effects on Convolvulus arvensis population dynamics in small grain organic cropping systems. Frontiers in Agronomy, 5.
