Decision support to reduce the nitrogen yield gap in organic agriculture

Project Director: Jason Kaye, Pennsylvania State University

Project overview

How much nitrogen (N) does an organic grain or silage corn crop need?  The answer depends on soil type and texture, active and total soil organic matter (SOM), soil and microbial carbon (C) and N dynamics, cover crop biomass and C:N ratio, and management practices. Overuse or underuse of fertilizer N can hurt the farm’s bottom line and compromise soil health. The Economic Optimum N Rate (EONR) depends on the cost of fertilizer, the farmgate price of organic corn, and the corn crop’s need for and response to added N, which decreases as the soil’s capacity to mineralize N increases. Organic producers need a tool to estimate that capacity and determine the EONR.

This project team, led by Jason Kaye at Penn State University, developed a model that predicts unfertilized corn yield, based on the N contributions of SOM and decomposing cover crops. This model has been integrated into an N decision support tool, which calculates the supplemental N fertilizer requirements for organic grain and silage corn in Pennsylvania.

The Penn State Web-based Nitrogen Credit Calculator

Farmer takeaways

  • There is a new nitrogen decision support tool available for corn growers.
  • The tool was developed with farmer input, and was tested on several organic farms representing a range of soil textures and SOM levels.
  • Users can compare how the cost of different nitrogen fertilizer options affect the recommended application rates, allowing farmers to consider profitability in their decision-making.

 

Project objectives and approach

Objectives:

  • Develop and refine an existing model into a decision support tool for organic farmers to determine the ENOR for their corn crop that considers N contributions from SOM and decomposing cover crop residues.
  • Test the model’s capacity to predict corn N requirements on a wide range of soil textures and SOM levels, and evaluate assumed values used in the model.
  • Develop the model into an online tool that accurately predicts EONR based on information entered by the user including %SOM, soil texture, N content and C:N ratio of cover crops, yield goal, N fertilizer cost, and farmgate price for corn.
  • Deliver the N decision support tool to farmers through multiple outreach venues.

Replicated field trials were conducted at the Penn State research station and several organic farms representing a range of soil textures and SOM levels. Corn was grown after several different cover crops, whose biomass, N content, and C:N ratio were measured at termination. Corn received 0, 50%, 100%, or 150% of the N recommended by the current version of the tool, using poultry feather meal (13-0-0), and corn grain yield and aboveground residue biomass were measured.

The prototype N decision tool, which included yield response curves from field trials and partial budget analysis, was tested by farmer participants in the project. The tool was refined and retested in an iterative process each year of the project. Improvements addressed the impacts of a wider range of soil textures and variations in actual C:N ratios of microbial biomass and SOM on N mineralization.

Key findings

  • In its most recent iteration, the decision support tool has accurately predicted yields of unfertilized corn and thereby can give good estimates of the EONR based on costs of organic N sources and farmgate prices for corn.
  • The tool is applicable to both organic and non-organic operations.
  • Key inputs to the model include the sand and clay content of the soil and the biomass, total N, and C:N ratio of the cover crop in addition to SOM percentage.
    • The project has developed a cover crop look-up table to facilitate accurate farmer estimates of cover crop residue N contribution.
  • The tool, updated annually based on new findings, is available online. 
Soil sample in the field

Resources

Penn State Nitrogen Decision Support Tool for Corn

Read More

Factsheet - Soil organic matter and cover crop-based nitrogen recommendations for corn

Read More

Journal Article - Improving a nitrogen mineralization model for predicting unfertilized corn yield. Arrington, K., et al., 2024.

Read More

USDA Project Report - OREI 2020-51300-32178

Read More

Location

Pennsylvania

Collaborators

Charles White, John Spargo, Kathleen Arrington, Brosi Bradley, Andrew Lefever, Madeline Luthard, Raziel Ordonez, Zoelie Rivera-Ocasio, Zack Sanders and Sarah Tierney, Penn State University

Denise Finney, Ursinus College

Region

Northeast

Topic

Soil Health, Crop Nutrient Management

Category

Grain and Field Crops

Year Published

2024