Participatory Breeding and Testing Networks: a Maize-based Case Study for Organic Systems
Project Director
Carmen A. Ugarte Diaz
Year Funded
2017
Award Number
2017-51300-27115
Funded Institution
University of Illinois
Grant Program
OREI (Organic Agriculture Research and Extension Initiative)
Project Overview
This project sought to enhance organic corn production and availability of high-quality, regionally adapted corn seed through:
(1) Farmer-participatory cultivar evaluation for yield, nitrogen (N) use efficiency, weed competitiveness, and feed grain quality (protein, methionine, lysine)
(2) Analysis of genetic and on-farm environmental and management factors in crop fitness and grain quality
(3) Study of soil health and soil-plant-microbiome factors in corn yield and quality
(4) Development of business models to address germplasm sharing and intellectual property (IP) issues and promote publicly supported cultivar development for organic systems.
A network of researchers and farmers tested corn cultivars from four breeding programs at 12 sites representing a range of environments and management practices (cash crop intensity, cropping system diversity, N fertility sources) to identify factors driving organic corn yields. Participants were interviewed to document management practices and farmer perceptions of agronomic, social, and legal (IP) challenges in organic corn breeding and seed production.
Hybrids developed under conventional management had higher yield and higher starch while organically bred hybrids were lower yielding with higher protein. Breeding efforts by project partner Mandaamin Institute focused on enhancing beneficial plant-microbe partnerships that enhance N fixation, N efficiency, and grain methionine content while maintaining yield.
Crop genetics and management (e.g., N rates) modulate corn root architecture. Steeper root angle (deeper rooting), and higher fine root biomass related to higher yield, while higher complexity (branching) of coarse roots was inversely related to yield and fine roots.
Farmer Takeaways
(1) The current IP regime (patents, contractual agreements) restricts access to genetic resources, stifles innovation, and hinders cultivar development for organic systems.
(2) Community-based approaches to seed sharing such as the Open Source Seed Initiative (OSSI) create a genetic commons and support innovation and cultivar development.
(3) Low vigor and weed, pest, and disease susceptibility of inbred lines and high cost of seed production limit availability of organic corn seed.
(4) Collaborative, farmer-participatory plant breeding networks can accelerate development of new cultivars better adapted to organic systems and organic farmers’ needs.
(5) Breeding and selection for enhanced plant-microbial partnerships can enhance crop resilience, nutrient use efficiency, and feed corn quality, including methionine content.
Project Outputs
A Primer on Plant Breeding and Intellectual Property Rights in Organic Seed Systems | eOrganic
Webinar: Corn Breeding for Organic Markets | eOrganic
Endres, A. B., J. Guarino, and N. Nathani. 2023. Intellectual property exhaustion, breeder frustration, and hindered innovation. Journal of Agriculture, Food Systems, and Community Development 12 (4).
Goldstein, W.A. 2023. The evolution of a partnership-based breeding program for organic corn. Journal of Agriculture, Food Systems, and Community Development 13 (1).
Mujjabi, C. 2022. The use of participatory breeding and testing networks in maize varietal development for organic systems. (M.S. Thesis. University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign).
